2540 Sutton Ave

What you could keep on this home

The buyer-agent commission at this price, minus the one-time CIY Package fee. Drag the slider to model any offer price.

About this home

Open Sun 1p - 3p | A Spacious & Classic Carmel Custom Build In Huntington Chase - Next to Coxhall Gardens and West Park - And a 10 Minute Bike Ride to Village of WestClay Shops and Restaurants | You'll appreciate the .6ac lot, primary bedrooms on both the main and upper floors (five total bedrooms), generous main floor office, solid wood doors and trim and the enormous, finished basement. | Investments: Water heater: 2026. Interior/exterior painting: 2026. Built-in oven & microwave: 2026. New electric stove top: 2024. Heat Pump AC: 2022 (w/ 10yr warranty with Thiele). Water softener, sump pump w/ batter back up and garage door opener: 2021. Furnace: 2018 (15yr warranty and serviced 2x/year by Thiele). New Anderson Windows: 2017. Architectural dimensional 30yr roof: 2010. Home has a 5-stage RO water filter drinking system, too. Don't miss your chance to call this house your home.

Nearby schools

• Towne Meadow Elementary SchoolRating: 9/10
  public · 0.5 mi · K-1-2-3-4-5
• Creekside Middle SchoolRating: 10/10
  public · 1.5 mi · 6-7-8
• Carmel High SchoolRating: 10/10
  public · 4.7 mi · 9-10-11-12
• University High School Of Indiana
  private · 0.6 mi · 9-10-11-12
• University High School of Indiana
  private · 0.6 mi · 9-10-11-12
• West Clay ElementaryRating: 9/10
  public · 1.3 mi · K-1-2-3-4-5

Recently sold nearby

• 1300 Woodpond N Roundabout—
  2026-08-28 · 4 bed · 3,238 sqft
• 12825 Clifford Cir—
  2026-08-28 · 4 bed · 2,729 sqft
• 11620 Victoria Ct—
  2026-08-28 · 4 bed · 2,260 sqft
• 3695 Brumley Way—
  2026-08-28 · 5 bed · 5,513 sqft
• 1884 Highland Cv—
  2026-08-27 · 4 bed · 4,422 sqft
• 1580 White Ash Dr—
  2026-08-27 · 4 bed · 3,270 sqft